Who managed Ghana’s World Cup campaign?

We are out of the 2014 FIFA World Cup. Thus the above question has to be asked. There will be more questions. After the Black Stars’ first round exit at Brazil 2014, the natural thing to do is to demand answers from those who managed affairs of the team in Brazil.

So, who managed Ghana’s World Cup campaign in the South American country? Was it the Youth and Sports Ministry? Was it the Ghana Football Association, the Black Stars Management Committee, the Technical Team or indeed, the campaign was managed by the five bodies?

 
By Ghana’s previous record at the competition, Brazil 2014 turned out to be the country’s poorest World Cup tournament, not really on the basis of the quality of play but of course, by the points garnered; one out of a likely nine and also by the fact that Ghana exited at the group stage.

At their maiden appearance in Germany 2006, the Black Stars’ 1/16th stage exit, losing 3-0 to Brazil was hailed. It was Ghana’s first time. More so, at the time when the other African teams had been disappointing, the Black Stars’ display was impressive. In South Africa 2010, when all Africa’s representatives failed to glitter, the Black Stars, remarkably, cruised to the quarter-final. They lost on penalties to Uruguay. Ghanaians and Africa as a whole were therefore right when they dreamt that the Black Stars would excel in Brazil. That didn’t happen.

The questions to ask are: what went wrong and who managed the World Cup campaign? The Black Stars might have drawn one and lost twice on the pitch but outside the pitch, there was no draw. The team lost everything. It’s either they didn’t have it or they lost all the things; the tranquility of mind, sound planning and the unity that teams usually need to progress at tourneys like the World Cup.

I was not in Brazil but all the off-the-pitch news reports I followed pointed to one thing: that, there was uneasy calm in the Black Stars camp. The GFA denied some of the reports and also confirmed the others especially when things got out of control.

I hate to dabble in unproven allegations. Professionally it is unethical. Morally, it is sinful to thrive on falsehood and even proceed to question people’s competence on that basis. Yet in a country where the first disposition of most authorities is to be defensive when they have failed to perform to expectation, the temptation for the public to feel hopeless is real.

Ours is an FA that appears to have specialized in not achieving anything significant with the Black Stars yet after every tournament they behave as if nothing went wrong. Player indiscipline was Ghana’s bane in Brazil. Indiscipline took centre stage in camp.

What was done by authorities in charge of the team when reports emerged that one of the players slept outside camp? That a player could have the effrontery to assault an FA official confirmed the height of indiscipline in camp. There were vehement denials of a "player revolt" but later events gave ample credence to the thick cloud of tension that hanged around Ghana’s camp because of players’ disrespect for authorities.

Players almost boycotted training because of unpaid appearance fee. Even after millions of dollars – cash were airlifted from Accra to Brasilia (and that was “unwise” according to Deputy Minister, Joseph Yamin but it had to be done), the team still couldn’t win. In all, the question remains: who managed Ghana's World Cup campaign?

If the South Africa 2010 quarter-final feat had been achieved authorities outside the playing body would have claimed some credit. Had the much-talked about semi-final or final dream also materialized, authorities again would have asked for some glory. All that didn’t happen. Ghana lost. The Black Stars had only one point. They exited early – at the group stage.

Whoever managed Ghana’s World Cup campaign must take full responsibility for this failure. Why did the players' appearance fee become a big issue? Why did the players threaten to boycott training? Why did a player sleep outside camp? How could a player assault an FA official? How could another player insult the coach? Ghanaians must have explanations to all that happened! Whoever managed our problem-ridden World Cup campaign must prepare to address the nation.

Enough of the distractions in Black Stars camp

GFA Spokesman, Ibrahim Saani Daara

It has in recent times become almost a ritual that, anytime Ghana, especially our senior national team, the Black Stars participate in international tournaments, certain developments which I call distractions, pop up. Eventually, instead of the Ghana Football Association (GFA) focusing primarily on what sent the team to the tournament, they rather engage the media; issuing press statements here and there to deny one issue or the other.

Again, in the end, the Black Stars don’t achieve their goal at the tourney. The GFA and sections of the media rather succeed in diverting everybody’s attention from the real issues. The team returns home with the promise of doing well at the next competition only for the media and the GFA “actors” to repeat or in fact, invent new forms of distractions at another tournament.

We have had enough of the ‘distractions’. It is high time we behaved seriously as a football country. We can’t continue to spend precious resources on football to the detriment of other equally important things only to go to tournaments to play with the intelligence of Ghanaians.

From the African Cup of Nations (AFCON) in Gabon-Equatorial Guinea in 2012, AFCON 2013 in South Africa and the latest, Brazil 2014, the GFA and sections of the media have had accusations and counter-accusations over the publication of stories which undoubtedly put Ghana in bad light not alone in the eyes of Ghanaians but also in the eyes of the whole world.

It may be natural to have negative developments in the camp of a team during a tournament. Yet it appears ours is becoming too much and unhealthy. It is high time we became serious and found civilized ways of managing affairs relative to bad developments in the Black Stars camp. It cannot be that journalists always wake up to fabricate stories about the team at tournaments.

When the Black Stars returned from AFCON 2012, there were damning reports of unbridled gambling in the team’s camp by the players. Stories about superstition and many other ridiculous tales were told by journalists who covered the team throughout the tournament. Not surprisingly, the came out to deny every bit of the information given by these journalists who were at the Gabon-Equatorial Guinea competition.

At AFCON 2013, the Ghana News Agency (GNA) ran a story that cited Ghana in a disparaging bribery story. Again, the GFA denied that story. They even went ahead to blame the GNA reporter at the tournament for putting out falsehood without initially contacting her. At one of Ghana’s matches in South Africa, there was a public, vitriolic exchange of abusive words between the FA spokesman and a GNA journalist, who, apparently, was wrongly accused.

Ghanaians up till now don’t know whether or not, what the GNA put out there was true. The GNA is not administered by angels so the tendency for them to make mistakes exist but given the credibility of the GNA overtime, it was hard for many people to accept the FA’s denial. How could the state-owned news agency lie about the national team? That issue, just like the Gabon-Equatorial Guinea one, died naturally after the GFA’s vehement denial.

Now this week in Maceio, Brazil, where the Black Stars are based, Myjoyonline.com reported of a "player revolt" in the team’s camp. The GFA was quick to deny that story too in a press release. They added that: the “Joy FM reporter in Maceio, Tony Bebli vehemently denied ever filing the report when he was confronted by Black Stars management and Asamoah Gyan”.

Like it happened in Gabon-Equatorial Guinea and in South Africa, the player “revolt story” in Maceio will die naturally but questions will remain. One of the questions will be whether it is simply journalists who have been fond of publishing falsehood about the Black Stars at tournaments or it’s rather the GFA which is always quick to sweep the truth under the carpet?

Whatever it is, let the GFA and all the “actors” in the continuing episodes of so-called false journalistic reportage and the GFA’s constant denials, be told, that, time, has a way of exposing liars. Such exposures are often embarrassing. The Black Stars and Gh

Talents alone don’t make a good league

The First Capital Plus Premier League

The self-adulation that characterizes the talk by Ghana Football Association (GFA) officials anytime they speak on the Ghana Premier League (GPL) is one that always fascinates me.

That the GPL is ranked third best in Africa and that it is better than South Africa’s Premier League Soccer (PSL) is a submission that has strongly been forced on us.

On Monday, May 19, 2014 GFA President Kwesi Nyantakyi, speaking in an insightful interview on Joy FM’s Brazil 2014 show said without any equivocation that, in terms of talent and by extension, player quality, the GPL’s is streets ahead of most African leagues including South Africa’s PSL. The FA President made valid points regarding his take on how some people gloss over Ghana’s poor economy to compare our club football to what pertains in England for example.

That comparison (references from England to compare with events in Ghana) has no basis because the English Premier League for example runs in an economy which is significantly stable and more developed than the economy of Ghana, said the FA President.

Factors contributing to the underdevelopment of our football clubs and the GPL can’t be disengaged from the bad state of Ghana’s economy. That, coming from the FA President was important. In developed economies and countries, football clubs aren’t only well-structured, they are also truly professional. They attract best of players and pay them very well.

League bodies in those countries formulate policies which accelerate the development of their leagues. They have adequate resources to support their development. In that case, we cannot overlook economic issues when discussing the development of the GPL. That is why the FA President, Kwesi Nyantakyi was right to say that, until our economy grows to the extent that, clubs can pay their players well, it will always be wrong to compare things here to Europe.

Having made this point, the FA President, thus surprised me when he said that because our league has many good talents, it is in fact, better than the PSL. How is that possible, Mr. President? Do talents alone make a league better? By virtue of his status at CAF, Kwesi Nyantakyi said he was well-informed on the state most African leagues.

The FA President is right but we are all witnesses to what goes on or what exists in other African countries in terms of league football. We can tell that, the GPL is behind in many respects. We ought to focus on improving the standards in organization and stop the self-adulation.

Whatever group that ranked the GPL third best in Africa recently had their own basis but we who closely follow events in the league know better. Let’s stop deceiving ourselves. Yes, we may have the player quality but what else does the GPL has to beat others on the continent?  

Infrastructure-wise, many GPL clubs still play on some terrible pitches. What has been the performance of our clubs in Africa in the last decade or more? What about the marketing and sponsorship issues of the GPL? How much money do our clubs earn from the marketing of the GPL? Does it compare favourably with what clubs in Tunisia, Morocco, Egypt, Algeria, etc. earn?

Despite being close to the end of the current season, the GFA/PLB have not rewarded last season’s league winner. Is that what happens in a professional Premier League? Isn’t it embarrassing that the FA still haven’t found something to give to the league champion? Where does this happen? I hate to make comparisons but will this be seen in the Tunisian, Moroccan, the Egyptian or South African Premier League which we think we are better than?
 
The GPL has talents but talents are nothing if the right conditions are not there to harness them. Talents add up to nothing if proper structures and resources are not in place to develop them. Talents amount to nothing if after exhibiting them in a whole season, no recognition is given to you like we have seen in the case of Kotoko since last season. Talents alone don’t make a league better, Mr GFA President.

Clubs in Ghana are poorly structured. They are badly managed. They have little or no resources to speed their development. They indeed have no serious plan for growth. I will not actually blame the FA for the poor administrative standards at our clubs but all that go to affect standards in the GPL and why should we be celebrating the poor standards, Mr. President?

13 years after May 9th Stadium Tragedy: Any lessons?

On a radio programme last year to discuss whether or not football fans and indeed the entire country have learnt any lesson, more than a decade after the May 9, 2001 Stadium Disaster; the conclusion was true yet pathetic. Panelists on the radio show – some very good ones – were unanimous in their opinion, that, Ghanaian football fans had learnt nothing from the horrific disaster that claimed 127 lives at the Accra Sports Stadium.

Today, as the country marks 13 years of what was easily the darkest day in Ghana football history, the same question will be asked again. Have we learnt anything worthy from that tragic event? With the litany of football-related violence, that have been seen at our stadiums from the last May 9 anniversary and throughout the last decade, my answer is no.

Our football authorities can talk so much about how well they have been committed to fighting the shameful acts of hooliganism. Numerous examples of how clubs including their officials have been sanctioned or punished for various acts of violence can be cited to back claims stemming hooliganism but to most critical and keen local football enthusiasts like me, again, the answer to that question will still be negative.

In my opinion, nothing has changed in our thoughts and attitudes; commitment and indeed the country’s resolve to shun the very acts that led to the needless deaths on May 9, 2001. It may be too harsh and unfair to describe league centres in Ghana as unsafe. Yet the fact that, the Ghana Football Association (GFA)’s Executive Committee, have in recent times been forced to close stadiums citing insecurity fully convinces me that our league centres are insecure.

That is sad commentary for a country like Ghana – a country that is known for many good things including football and in fact, a country that proudly sees football as its passion. This is the time for every stakeholder of the game in Ghana to wake up to the reality that, not much has been done to fight football-related violence.

No sane Ghanaian would wish that an incident of the magnitude of the May 9 Stadium disaster or even less recurs. However, the plain truth is that, the possibility of a recurrence is high, if the Police look on as brazen miscreants (I don’t call them football fans) but rather social misfits, invade league centres and unleash violence on state property and precious human lives.

It is depressing to recall that, from the last time the May 9 2001 tragedy was commemorated, not only have we seen coaches and players threatened with violence; police vehicles, team buses and sadly, police personnel including referees have additionally been assaulted. Properties running into thousands of Ghana cedis have equally been destroyed.

It is on record that, Referee Kwame Kyei who was mercilessly beaten at the Bordie Park in March this year (and died later) did not die as a result of the assault on him. But the mere fact that a referee can be subjected to such heartless assault does no good to the talk about whether any lesson has been learnt from the May 9 Stadium Tragedy.

The preceding assertion totally indicts the image of Ghana football and all who have the country’s football at heart must be sad! Today, government officials, FA authorities, Hearts and Kotoko representatives, supporters’ leaders, families of the 127 victims, the media, etc. will gather around the May 9 statute at the Accra stadium to commemorate the terrible event.

Sermons will be preached; admonitions will be given on why hooliganism ought to be eschewed; there will be donations for families of the victims and that will be the end. It will end there because, from the first May 9 anniversary till date, that is what the country has been doing.

We haven’t done enough to fight football violence. We have allowed football fans to continue to visiting their violence on state properties and precious human lives. That must end now. My appeal to the FA and the Police is that, proactive measures should be taken at identifying; arresting, prosecuting and where appropriate jailing football hooligans. Otherwise, Ghana will not make any headway in stemming football-related violence.